If you’re looking for extra foam and padding on your bed, a queen pillow top mattress should, by all means, be at the top of your list of preferences.
It can ease your back pain and neck pain problems by helping in maintaining a natural posture throughout the night. But again, not all queen pillow top mattress models work the same.
Some are a big disappointment due to a couple of flaws here and there.
Below we compare 10 pillow top mattresses in order to observe which one(s) of them offers the best combination of features and value for money.
Classic Brands Cool Gel Ultimate 14″ Plush Gel Memory Foam Mattress
If you are looking for that perfect night’s sleep, then the Classic Brands Cool Gel Ultimate 14″ mattress is sure to win you over. It is ideal for people who wish for a soft yet supportive queen pillow top mattress that provides both give and temperature regulation throughout the night. The mattress is available in queen, California king, twin XL, king, twin and full sizes and combines two leading sleep technologies at unbeatable value and quality.
- This 14″ queen pillow top mattress depth includes the following layers 2″ top layer of ventilated Cool Gel foam that enhances airflow throughout the mattress, 2″ of Memory Foam that reduces tossing and turning, 8″ of High density base foam and 2″ Comfort Foam to provide extra support and comfort for a good night sleep.
- 10 Years full warranty and 15 pro-rated plus two free gel pillow tops included with California king, full, king, full-xl and queen sizes and one gel pillow top with twin/xl.
- Features new improved design with waterfall edge cotton knit cover and a contrasting border.
- CertiPUR-US certified.
- Helps in relieving pressure points
- This queen pillow top mattress is suitable for all types of sleepers
- Has a cooling effect as it draws heat away from the body
- The firmness of the mattress is a bit inconsistent
Sleep Master Ultima Comfort 10″ Pillow Top Spring Mattress
In the event that you are searching for a reasonable queen pillow top mattress that provides for you the best pocket loop and memory foam, this is a great option at a great cost. Sleep Master Ultima® Comfort 10 Inch Pillow Top Spring Mattress, Full is a perfect combination of both supple spring support firmness, plush, and soft body conforming comfort. In addition, it comes in queen, twin, short queen and full sizes, and in several thickness levels to help you get the exact level of firmness you need.
- Features an iCoil system with hundreds of independent iCoils that provide durable support while minimizing motion transfer from a sleeping partner.
- This queen pillow top mattress layer includes 1″ layer of Pressure Relieving Comfort Foam, 1.5″ of Comfort Foam, a High-density foam layer and a 7.5″ layer of iCoil spring unit to provide maximum support.
- The memory foam padding is CertiPUR-US approved for content, durability, and performance.
- Odor free
- 10 year limited warranty against damage from normal use or shipping or from faulty construction
- This queen pillow top mattress can be used with or without a frame box spring
- Mattress cover is not removable although it can be spot cleaned easily
Dreamfoam Bedding Ultimate Dreams Crazy Quilt Pillow Top Mattress
This is an ultra plush memory foam ideal for side sleepers and people with lower back pain, muscle injuries, headaches or neck pain and even for pregnant women. You can get it in short queen, California king, full/XL, king, twin/XL and queen sizes hence it works on all types of beds from traditional frame beds to day and trundle beds. What’s more, Dreamfoam Bedding Ultimate Dreams Crazy Quilt Pillow Top Mattress, Short Queen is 100 percent made in the USA using USA-made materials, therefore, quality is guaranteed.
- This queen pillow top mattress features a TriZone Foam core for extra support. This feature also helps in reducing or eliminating virtually motion transfer between sleeping partners.
- The foams are CertiPUR-US guaranteed to meet all regulations for safety and environmental quality.
- Boasts are not too firm not too soft-medium feel thereby allowing your body weight to be distributed evenly to relieve pressure points.
- Comes shipped direct to your home in a compressed, rolled package that is easy to decompress.
- This queen pillow top mattress allows for contouring to your body
- Great packaging and fast shipping
- Stomach sleepers find it too soft
Classic Brands 10.5″ Cool Gel Ventilated Memory Foam Mattress
Built keeping in mind the restless schedules of modern day people and thus works great for delivering them maximum comfort, this queen pillow top mattress is medium, not too firm or too soft. Classic Brands 10.5-Inch Cool Gel Ventilated Memory Foam Mattress, Queen is built to support every part of the body evenly and adjust to your body’s weight and temperature. In addition, the mattress features a complete, stress-free and luxurious support that enables the spine to stay aligned.
- Boasts a 2″ top Cool Gel memory foam layer that is ventilated to allow air to circulate thereby creating a cooler sleeping surface.
- The Gel-infused memory foam feature also helps in retaining the pressure relieving properties of traditional memory foam hence tossing and turning are great diminished.
- This queen pillow top mattress is covered with detailed knit top and charcoal gray knit sides for breathability and is available in queen, California king, twin XL, king, twin and full sizes.
- Features 6.5″ support base layer that maintains the strength of the mattress and two 1″ layers of Poly Gel-Supportive Foam that offers support for the Gel Foam layer.
- Resistant to dust mites, allergens, bacteria and mold
- CertiPUR-US certified to ensure environmental and personal safety
- Boasts a 10-year warranty
- Produces a strong funny smell after unwrapping the pack but usually, goes away within 48 hours
Signature Sleep Signature 13″ Independently-Encased Coil Mattress
If you’re looking for a large firm, soft and comfortable queen pillow top mattress for your home then Signature Sleep Signature 13″ makes the cut. It offers a perfect combination of comfort and superiority that you would expect in high-end queen pillow top mattress but at a great price. The multiple foam layers are CertiPUR-US certified to meet specific criteria for physical performance, environmental stewardship, and indoor emissions.
- Made using 100% Rayon from Bamboo fabric hence absorbs moisture, dries quickly and insulates when you’re cold and ventilate if you are hot.
- Features a foam pillow top with 1 inch 3-Zone foam to offer a lower body and soft upper comfort with a firmer center to support hips and the lower back.
- This queen pillow top mattress boasts 10 inches of Independently Encased Coil springs that are optimized specifically to contour to your body to help in balancing the weight distribution.
- Comes with a pillow top for additional comfort
- Affordable and odor-free
- Provides excellent back support
- Quite heavy hence, difficult to move in the house alone
Sleep Innovations Taylor 12″ Gel Swirl Memory Foam Mattress
Made in the USA from premium foamed and swirled cooling gels, this queen pillow top mattress is equipped with an enhanced airflow feature to provide you with the best temperature when sleeping. Sleep Innovations Taylor 12-inch Gel Swirl Memory Foam Mattress, Queen offers advanced spinal alignment to your body thereby giving you a healthy sleeping experience. This makes it ideal for all types of sleepers including side, stomach and back sleeper. If you normally toss and turn while sleeping, this would be a good bet.
- Features TriComfort design with 2″ Cool plush top layer, 2″ Air Channel Foam middle layer to support the air flow and 8″ ultra support bottom layer.
- Has a medium-firm feel, personalized alignment and proven pressure point relief for the average to bigger body.
- Includes 20-year limited warranty so there is nothing to lose by purchasing this queen pillow top mattress as it will last for a long period of time.
- Sleeps cool
- Less motion transfer
- Great for back pain
- Has the chemical memory foam that smell but usually, it dissipates with time
Textrade USA Inner Spring Pillow Top Mattress in A Box
Though Textrade may not be an incredibly well-known brand name, Textrade USA Inner Spring Pillow Top Mattress in A Box, Queen specifically stands out because of its inner spring pillow top design. This design provides body support and minimizes motion disturbances. Therefore, when you toss or turn, get into or out of the bed, your partner won’t feel your movements. It comes with a 5-year limited warranty long enough to cover any premature deterioration.
- Features a plush 3″ pillow topper that consists of 20 layers of Denier foam with Damask quilted fabric cover.
- The foam padding used in the pillow top boasts 1000 15-gauge tempered steel coils which work to provide firm body support and reduce motions disturbances.
- Includes a border wire around the perimeter of this queen pillow top mattress that ensures the edge of the bed doesn’t slump.
- Comes in a box with wheels and a handle making it easy for a single person to move around as it’s quite heavy.
- Sold at reasonable and affordable price
- Provides a restful night
- Easy to set-up
- Edges of this queen pillow top mattress may be too soft making sitting on the edge of the bed a little difficult
Classic Brands Mercer 12″ Hybrid Cool Gel Memory Foam and Inner Spring Mattress
This is a well-built memory foam mattress that is recommended for different types of sleeping positions. Classic Brands Mercer 12 Inch Hybrid Cool Gel Memory Foam and Innerspring Mattress provides great support, contouring and cradling effect and personalized worthy of a memory mattress safe from memory retention worries. You will find it easier to fall and stay asleep with this queen pillow top mattress under you.
- Boasts a 0.5″ gel infused top layer memory foam for dispersing heat, two 0.25″ layers of comfy foam, additional 0.5″ of comfort foam, another 0.75″ layer of foam and 8″ base layer made of individually standing coils.
- Comes with a quilted pillow top knit cover that is beautifully finished with corded edges and coordinating knit sides for maximum breathability.
- Has individually wrapped inner springs that move independently to reduce motion transfer.
- CertiPUR-US certified and comes with a 10-year warranty.
- Relieves pressure points
- No maintenance is need
- Mattress base/foundation not included
Sarah Peyton 10″ Queen Memory Foam Firm Support Mattress
Sarah Peyton 10-Inch Queen Memory Foam Firm Support Mattress with 2 Contour Pillows comprises two separate layers which are intertwined to provide you with great back support thus helping eliminate pain/aches. It is 100% hypoallergenic which is perfect for people with allergies. In addition, the queen pillow top mattress never needs to be turned as it can always be conveniently used with any platform bed or box springs available.
- Includes a removable zippered velour cover that is ultra soft and easy to clean and two bonus pillows.
- Includes 2.5″ viscoelastic foam top layer on a 7.5″ polyurethane base foam layer.
- Its supportive high-density memory foam helps in alleviating back pain linked with traditional mattresses.
- Made using a combination of next generation memory foam over an energy absorbing Intellifoam polyurethane base to give you customized support and comfort that your body needs.
- Resistant to odor-causing germs, mold, and mildew
- This queen pillow top mattress meets all federal flammability standards
- Available in queen, twin, king and full sizes and is an economical choice for anyone
- The firmness of this queen pillow top mattress is very inconsistent
Best Price Mattress 10 Inch Independent Operating Coil Euro Top Spring Mattress
This may be a cheap queen pillow top mattress but by no means is it poor quality. Best Price Mattress 10 Independent Operating Coil Euro Top Spring Mattress is a great mattress that will help you sleep undisturbed. It has been tested to exceed both durability and longevity hence it’s a great investment.
- Features 7″, 12 gauge independent operating pocketed coils that provide an equal weight distribution by contouring the curves of your body hence relieving your pressure points.
- Includes premium knitted poly-Jacquard fabric cover that encases the entire mattress.
- This queen pillow top mattress boasts three main layers including 1-inch comfort layer, 1.5-inch premium comfort foam layer and 0.5-inch high-density support foam layer.
- Comes with a 10-year warranty from the manufacturer.
- Firm and fits perfectly on all bed types
- Provides a soft, gentle, comfortable night sleep
- May feel too firm for the first few nights
Tips on Choosing Pillow Top Mattresses
Consider the following when shopping for a new queen pillow top mattress:
- Level of softness and firmness
- Length of warranty
- Sleep preferences — side or back sleeper
- Level of comfort
- Size of the pillow top mattress
Why Choose a Queen Pillow Top Mattress?
- Relatively easy to maintain
- They offer luxurious softness and extra comfort
- Features sophisticated spring systems to keep movement isolated
- Ideal for both side and back sleepers
- Lasts longer than traditional mattresses
- Helps in alleviating back pains and reducing tossing and turning at night
Each one of these queen pillow top mattress units has its benefits and disadvantages. Sleep Master Ultima Comfort 10" is a worthy competitor for the top spot but it loses out marginally due to the fact that the queen pillow top mattress cover is not removable. The second runner-up in our top list is Best Price Mattress 10 Inch Independent Operating Coil Euro Top Spring Mattress which only misses out on the top position due to the extra firmness that is experienced in the first few days of using it.
The overall winner among our queen pillow top mattress reviews is Classic Brands Cool Gel Ultimate 14" Plush Mattress – its pros clearly outweigh its cons. It offers adequate depth, chiropractic benefits and extended durability with its only downside being inconsistent firmness (rarely reported). Having done extensive research on this subject, our verdict is that Classic Brands Cool Gel Ultimate 14" Plush clearly deserves the top-most spot.